1147 Highway 35
Middletown, NJ 07748

Mon: 9:00AM - 8:00PM

Tue: 9:00AM - 6:00PM

Wed: 9:00AM - 5:00PM

Thu: 9:00AM - 8:00PM

Fri: 9:00AM - 6:00PM

Sat: 8:00AM - 1:00PM

Sun: Closed

93.0% would refer friends and family to us

1 stars Verified customer

This is the first bad review I have had for Eyes First unfortunitly it is also my last since I won't be going back. I was told that due to my having "border line" glaucoma readings I should be checked every 6 months. That sounded judicous to me so I agreed. This last appointment (which only costs me a $50 co-payment) was only half done since one of the machines used to test eye pressure was "on loan" to another office in another town and I would have to go there to have that test done. Oh, by the way, it would cost me another $50 out of my pocket. The only appointment available was at a day and time that was unacceptable.

The icing on this cake was the doctor decided that I had "dry eye" and needed to buy some special wipes and she needed to see me for a follow-up in two weeks (another $50) I said I was just here less than 6 months ago did I have this condition then? She said yes, but it did not appear as severe, did she even mention it at the time? No. The follow-up could not wait til my next appointment in 6 months. Now, they were only getting $50 form me at a clip, but they were charging my insurance hundreds of dollars. I don't think this is a money making scam on their part. Like I said, they seem like they give a good eye exam. They DO need to review their office practices and spend some of the money coming in to give each office their own equipment. For me there are dozens and dozens of eye doctors in the area and my business will be with one of them.

5 stars Verified customer

I have been going to Eyes First in Middletown for years. Love the entire team ... they are so friendly! Service is great and Dr. Gershenow is the best.

5 stars Verified customer

Nice doctor, nice staff.

5 stars Verified customer

The staff here are very polite, friendly and professional. Dr. Gershenow did a complete exam, answered all of my questions. He didn't rush me out the door and made sure I was well informed on the issues that affect my specific eye health. I would recommend Dr. Gershenow to everyone.

5 stars Verified customer

I have been a patient at Eyes First for many years. If not for the comprehensive, excellent service the Doctors and staff there provide, it would not have been "many years". I would recommend Eyes First without any equivocation.

5 stars Verified customer

Dr. Todd Gershenow is attentive, communicative and patient - he always explains procedures and products clearly and completely. The rest of the staff is equally terrific. Everyone is knowledgeable and helpful. I have been a patient at Eyes First - Middletown for many years and have always recommended them to friends!

4 stars Verified customer

The Dr was great, so was the staff, but they had issues finding my correct insurance information at first and told me it wouldn't cover glasses, and higher copay than it should be. They shined up my current glasses without me asking.

5 stars Verified customer

As always, great service by great peoople who really care. Every experience I've had has been professional, consistent and thorough. My whole family has been going there for years and will continue to. I recommend Eyes First to anyone who can't see. Ha, ha.

5 stars Verified customer

The staff is friendly, warm and very accommodating to my schedule. I always have had a wonderful experience at the Middletown location.

5 stars Verified customer

Doctor was really nice and addressed all of my questions and concerns.